Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
Page 1 of 3 • Share •
Page 1 of 3 • 1, 2, 3 
Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
Have sold more handguns this year than I have bought...
Been getting the "hots" lately for a S&W 500...Those of you who have one...anything I should know about.....what are the gotcha's if anything...I see they have a compensated model.
I'm planning on being a wus and loading it down
Been getting the "hots" lately for a S&W 500...Those of you who have one...anything I should know about.....what are the gotcha's if anything...I see they have a compensated model.
I'm planning on being a wus and loading it down

msredneck- Contributing Member

- Posts: 13028
Join date: 2009-04-20
Age: 53
Location: Clinton, MS
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
Just the price of the initial ammo. Unless you start out with unloaded brass

BigDaddyQ- Distinguished Poster

- Posts: 1269
Join date: 2011-08-11
Age: 34
Location: Madison
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
well - I'll have to man up and buy a few boxes of commercial ammo...
I doubt you can buy 500 S&W brass from someone like Starline...
I'll pour my own bullets eventually.....
That Big ole revolver just turns me on....
I doubt you can buy 500 S&W brass from someone like Starline...
I'll pour my own bullets eventually.....
That Big ole revolver just turns me on....

msredneck- Contributing Member

- Posts: 13028
Join date: 2009-04-20
Age: 53
Location: Clinton, MS
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
I'd love to hunt with one. I'd settle for a .44 Mag if I had one of those.

jbpmidas- Contributing Member

- Posts: 7177
Join date: 2009-05-21
Age: 33
Location: Amory, MS
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
I have no interest in hunting with one...cept I'd luv to waste a hog up close and personal....
Just want one cause its Freakin BIG !
Just want one cause its Freakin BIG !

msredneck- Contributing Member

- Posts: 13028
Join date: 2009-04-20
Age: 53
Location: Clinton, MS
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
Me 2 but you said talk you out of it. I WANT a .50BMG too!

BigDaddyQ- Distinguished Poster

- Posts: 1269
Join date: 2011-08-11
Age: 34
Location: Madison
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
I had one for a while (the one in my profile) and recoil wise it wasn't as bad as a Super Blackhawk with hot Cor Bons. But I did wear shooting glove while shooting it. I let it go after a few years. I wish it had been a shorter barreled version. Like a 5" model.

Jarhead5811- Distinguished Poster

- Posts: 798
Join date: 2011-07-15
Age: 37
Location: Gluckstadt, MS
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
Neck, please don't buy a short-barreled S&W 500. Get 6" are LONGER.....
Yes, Starline does make 500 S&W brass. Look at Midway USA.....
I too vote for plinking with medium loads using cast bullets. More FUN and less PAIN...........(and $$$$).
.
Yes, Starline does make 500 S&W brass. Look at Midway USA.....
I too vote for plinking with medium loads using cast bullets. More FUN and less PAIN...........(and $$$$).
.

SubGunFan- Contributing Member

- Posts: 4515
Join date: 2009-05-25
Age: 55
Location: Jackson
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
As you know, I have one ... they are good for absolutely NOTHING!! Was fun at the beginning .... sits in the safe now ....
Told a guy the other day that I only load it down for plinking ... he responded back; why in the hell do you have it then if you do not shoot it for what is was made for ... got me to thinking - he is right.
Took the 686 out for the past three days shooting the back plate rack at Magnolia - 100 rds each day ..... now that is fun ... a lot more than the 500S&W.
If you are going to reload - well, not if but when because commercial rounds are around $50-$60 for a box of 20. Remember, even when you download them, that is still a lot of powder -- gaschecks are between 5-7 cents each ...
If I had not promised my youngest son he could have it (later on), I would probably sell it and find me a nice .45LC.
Told a guy the other day that I only load it down for plinking ... he responded back; why in the hell do you have it then if you do not shoot it for what is was made for ... got me to thinking - he is right.
Took the 686 out for the past three days shooting the back plate rack at Magnolia - 100 rds each day ..... now that is fun ... a lot more than the 500S&W.
If you are going to reload - well, not if but when because commercial rounds are around $50-$60 for a box of 20. Remember, even when you download them, that is still a lot of powder -- gaschecks are between 5-7 cents each ...
If I had not promised my youngest son he could have it (later on), I would probably sell it and find me a nice .45LC.
_________________
----------------------------------------
To be sure of hitting the target, shoot first
and call whatever you hit the target.
“Remember the first rule of gunfighting... ‘have a gun.’"
-Col. Jeff Cooper

captain-03- Moderator

- Posts: 11718
Join date: 2009-04-16
Age: 60
Location: Byram, MS
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
I didn't mean to sound like in was recommending a short barreled model. I just wish mine had been one so it could serve as a bear gun, or something, being I couldn't bring myself to try and hunt with it.
A .460 sounds better it'll take .454 and .45 Long Colts
A .460 sounds better it'll take .454 and .45 Long Colts

Jarhead5811- Distinguished Poster

- Posts: 798
Join date: 2011-07-15
Age: 37
Location: Gluckstadt, MS
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
Go ahead and get one. With all you sold, some money must have musta fell 'tween the cracks. Get one of the original 72 oz. ones. Fella like you needs a big un.
sidroski- Contributing Member

- Posts: 5609
Join date: 2009-05-11
Location: Florence MS
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
Do it. Period.

3spop- Contributing Member

- Posts: 1458
Join date: 2009-05-24
Age: 37
Location: Clarksdale
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
Do it! I shoot 440 grain gc's out of mine loaded with 10 grains of Trail Boss and it recoils less than a 44 magnum. My 4" shoots pretty good too, I want to kill a deer with it this year if I can get within 50 yards. A 1/2" hole going in and comming out should leave a good blood trail!
J.B.

J.B.


cottonmouth- Distinguished Poster

- Posts: 1375
Join date: 2010-03-16
Age: 41
Location: Copiah County
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
cottonmouth wrote: Do it! I shoot 440 grain gc's out of mine loaded with 10 grains of Trail Boss and it recoils less than a 44 magnum. My 4" shoots pretty good too, I want to kill a deer with it this year if I can get within 50 yards. A 1/2" hole going in and comming out should leave a good blood trail!
J.B.
Is that your EDC?

jbpmidas- Contributing Member

- Posts: 7177
Join date: 2009-05-21
Age: 33
Location: Amory, MS
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
cottonmouth wrote: Do it! I shoot 440 grain gc's out of mine loaded with 10 grains of Trail Boss and it recoils less than a 44 magnum. My 4" shoots pretty good too, I want to kill a deer with it this year if I can get within 50 yards. A 1/2" hole going in and comming out should leave a good blood trail!
J.B.
That looks like Hellboy's gun

dbarnes357- Veteran Poster

- Posts: 435
Join date: 2010-12-20
Location: Jackson

cottonmouth- Distinguished Poster

- Posts: 1375
Join date: 2010-03-16
Age: 41
Location: Copiah County
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
cottonmouth wrote: EDC?
J.B.
Every Day Carry.

fastarrow- Distinguished Poster

- Posts: 603
Join date: 2009-04-16
Age: 42
Location: Ocean Springs
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
Talk you out of it? Costs like hell, kicks like hell, hurts like hell, bullets expensive as hell.
Sounds like fun huh?
Sounds like fun huh?

sand_man- Distinguished Poster

- Posts: 1141
Join date: 2009-05-24
Age: 55
Location: George County
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
I thought you were selling off...did you hit the lottery again, Neck?
Re: Mulling over a S&W 500 - talk me out of it
"Is that your EDC?"
I was going to say yes beacuse I thought EDC was extinct dinosaur cartridge……..
J.B.
I was going to say yes beacuse I thought EDC was extinct dinosaur cartridge……..
J.B.

cottonmouth- Distinguished Poster

- Posts: 1375
Join date: 2010-03-16
Age: 41
Location: Copiah County
Page 1 of 3 • 1, 2, 3 
Similar topics» Playoff Talk
» Scores Talk
» GUESTS YOU CAN TALK TO EACHOTHER HERE
» Lets talk capacitors
» Mao Asada and Yu-Na Kim Japan Open Rival Talk
» Scores Talk
» GUESTS YOU CAN TALK TO EACHOTHER HERE
» Lets talk capacitors
» Mao Asada and Yu-Na Kim Japan Open Rival Talk
Page 1 of 3
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum




